Not quite nickel and dimed

When I read Barbara Ehrenreich's Nickel and Dimed, I kept thinking that surely things were not as bad as she made it seem.  Ms. Ehrenreich, a college professor, decided to get by as a minimum wage worker. She describes stints at Wal-mart and how precarious things were. As an example of the things that seemed totally ridiculous: she lived in a hotel for nearly $3000/month supposedly because she couldn't come with the one month deposit of about $500 to live in an apartment.

When I came to this country, I had $700 in my pocket and nothing else. Well, not quite nothing else. I had a fellowship from Ohio State worth about $1100/month.  Regardless, though, not only did I live for 1.5 years on $1100/month ... I had a couple thousand dollars in the bank when I graduated with my Masters degree.  It all, I think, comes down to making somewhat intelligent choices.  For example, I ate out perhaps 10 times in my months in Columbus, and I'm including fast food lunches in that total.

Looks like someone else had the same impression on reading her book.  He, however, was curious enough to spend nearly a year disproving "Nickel and Dimed".  Adam Shepard walked into a homeless shelter with $25. 10 months later, he had an apartment, a truck and $5000 in the bank.

To be fair to Barbara Ehrenreich, one thing about her book strikes me as particularly germane: that most poor people in America are one illness away from disaster. The cost of healthcare is the one big difference between the world she describes and the one that Adam Shepard and I encountered. We were young and healthy.


  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  3. Can I just point out that $1100 a month plus $700 for a single person with no dependents or major health problems is a lot of money?

    Also, I think we should be scared whenever we use words like "It all comes down to" or "it's as simple as". If we find ourselves using those phrases some part of our brain should signal that we're probably leaving the realm of reality, where nothing is "that simple" and when it is takes true genius to boil complex concepts down to something that is both simple and true.

    Adam Shepard thinks "it all comes down to" ones' attitude. Supposedly if one is willing to work hard, one is guaranteed to succeed. Does this mean that the "working poor" are really not hard workers? All of those maids and fry cooks, the day laborers supporting families, they all just need to work harder. Yeah, right, they don't work hard enough.

    You say that "it all comes down to" making intelligent choices. You assume: choices and intelligence. You had a fellowship to attend a university, are you not aware that your intellect is higher than most? Do you really believe that this is something for which you are responsible?

    It's really shocking that so many healthy privileged young people think that the difference between them and the poor is they're willing to eat Ramen noodles. Credit history, illness, family responsibilities, intellect, natural temperament, family history, criminal record...NONE of that is what it's about. It's about Ramen noodles.